A Magic opening hand should be judged by whether it can start the deck’s plan, not by how many powerful cards it contains. The London mulligan lets you draw seven again, then put one card on the bottom of your library for each mulligan that counts. It offers more selection, but being down a card remains a real cost.
How the London mulligan works
- Each player draws their starting hand, normally seven cards.
- The starting player declares first whether they will keep or mulligan, followed by the other players in turn order.
- Players taking a mulligan shuffle their hand into their library and draw their starting hand size again.
- They put a number of cards equal to their counted mulligans on the bottom in any order.
- Once a player keeps, that opening hand is final.
After one mulligan in a two-player game, you choose six cards from seven. After two, you keep five. There is no automatic scry.
The multiplayer and Brawl exception
In multiplayer games and in every Brawl game, a player’s first mulligan does not count toward the cards put on the bottom. In multiplayer Commander, your first replacement hand can therefore still contain seven cards. State the game type before drawing so nobody applies the free mulligan in the wrong setting.
Four checks before keeping
| Check | Useful question | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Mana | Can I cast my early spells with these sources and colours? | No source, one fragile source or mismatched colours |
| Curve | Do I have a realistic play in the first turns? | Only expensive cards and no bridge |
| Plan | Do these cards advance the deck’s main plan? | Strong cards with no shared purpose |
| Interaction | Can I handle the likely pace of the opponent? | Too slow, or all answers and no pressure |
Your mana base and mana curve provide the structural context. Two lands can be ideal for a low-curve deck and risky for a deck that must reach four mana.
The Poke-Geek sixty-second method
Count usable sources
Check colours, lands that enter tapped and acceleration. Three lands are not enough if none casts the spell that makes the hand work.
Simulate the first three turns
Lay out the plays you can make without assuming perfect draws. If the sequence needs two exact topdecks, the hand is less stable than it looks.
Name the card that gives the hand a purpose
Look for early pressure, card advantage, ramp or interaction. A keepable hand needs a clear role, not necessarily a spectacular card.
Respect the cost of going down a card
Six stable cards are usually better than seven unplayable ones, but repeatedly searching for an ideal combination quickly reduces your resources.
What should go on the bottom?
Keep the core that makes the hand function. Bottom the most redundant, expensive or poorly timed card. Do not remove a land automatically: if the remaining hand can no longer produce its colours, the mulligan has not solved the problem.
- Keep the sources needed for the opening turns.
- Preserve at least one action that supports the deck’s role.
- Remove duplicates that add nothing early.
- Do not keep a card only because it is rare or powerful.
Adjust for the deck and format
Aggro generally needs mana, pressure and follow-up. Control may accept a slower hand with enough lands and suitable answers. Combo must separate an essential piece from a card that matters only after the combo is assembled. In Limited, stable colours and early creatures often matter more than an impressive late card.
In Commander, the free mulligan is not a reason to hunt the same opener every game. Look for mana, development and at least one useful decision. The Magic FINAL FANTASY Starter Kit is a good example of a learning environment where a simple playable sequence matters more than a theoretical perfect hand.
Common mistakes
- keeping no lands because the spells are strong;
- treating three lands of the wrong colours as stable mana;
- mulliganing a sound hand to find one specific card;
- forgetting that the free first mulligan is for multiplayer and Brawl;
- bottoming a card before the procedure requires it;
- revealing a decision too early and influencing other players.
Keep checklist
- Do I have the right mana colours?
- Can I act in the opening turns?
- Does the hand support my deck’s plan?
- Does it require overly specific draws?
- Does this format grant a free first mulligan?
- What would I bottom after another mulligan?
Once play begins, announce actions clearly; our guide to the stack and priority in Magic continues the method. The best mulligan does not promise a win. It turns a confused hand into a realistic plan.